Capital Punishment Essay: Hypocrisy of the Death Penalty

The Hypocrisy of the Death Penalty If there is a desire by the American people to maintain the death penalty, let us at least be spared the hypocrisy of a justification by example. The death penalty is a penalty, to be sure, a frightful torture, both physical and moral, but it provides no sure example except a demoralizing one. It punishes, but it forestalls nothing indeed, it whitethorn even arouse the impulse to murder. It hardly seems to exist, except for the man who suffers it-- in his soul for months and years, in his body during the desperate and violent hour when he is faded in two without suppressing his life. Let us call it by the name which, for lack of any other brilliance, will at least give the nobility of truth, and let us recognize it for what it is essentially a revenge. A punishment that penalizes without forestalling is indeed called revenge. It is a quasi-arithmetical reply made by society to whoever breaks its pristine law. That reply is as old as man it is ca lled the law of retaliation. Whoever has done me harm must suffer harm whoever has put out my eye m...